I have spent a large part of this weekend analyzing 2 games for the DP challenge.  One of the games, Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories, strikes me as really poor game design even though the franchise is extremely popular and Rockstar is a well-known and popular developer.  The other, Kick-Ass, is by Frozen Codebase, a small local indie company.  Based on the movie of the same title, this game hardly stands a chance of positive reviews.  In doing the DP Challenge, I found that there is not a single movie-based game on the Top 100 list.  I was surprised to find this, since I actually thought one of the Star Wars-based games might have made the list. 

Kick-Ass provides polished play with solid play mechanics and yet, it will be harshly panned by reviewers.  Meanwhile, the entire GTA franchise has been embraced by reviewers and the public alike despite poor physics and uninspiring missions.  I understand the reasons for this, but I still find this phenomenon both fascinating and disappointing.